Best Homemade Cocktail Sauce (Seafood Sauce)
Homemade Cocktail Sauce Recipe – This 5-minute recipe for zippy, zesty seafood sauce requires only a handful of ingredients and is easily adjustable to your liking. You’ll never buy jarred cocktail sauce again!
Why We Love This Best Cocktail Sauce Recipe
I can honestly say it’s been at least 14 years since I purchased a cocktail sauce jar.
After all, why would I spend the extra cash to buy a lesser-quality product when the homemade version is so quick, cheap, and easy to make?
By simply combining a handful of simple ingredients you (most likely) already have in your fridge, you can make the most flavorful, tangy, absolute BEST Cocktail Sauce Recipe you have ever tried. I promise that you will definitely not miss the jarred stuff.
And of course, you can adjust it to taste and preferences! I love adding an extra dash of hot sauce to make a spicy dip for my shrimp cocktail, or including a bit more minced garlic for enjoying on a seafood pizza.
What Ingredients You Need For Seafood Sauce
- Ketchup – Essential for the perfect tomato base of a great cocktail sauce, and offers a hint of sweetness.
- Fresh lemon juice – The acidity needed to brighten all of the ingredients.
- Worcestershire sauce – Adds a smoky, earthy depth of flavor. Use a vegan version to make this entire recipe vegan-friendly.
- Prepared horseradish – This gives the cocktail sauce its signature spicy zippiness.
- Minced garlic – Helps to balance the spice of the horseradish.
- Hot sauce (optional) – If you want to make an even spicier sauce! The best option here is Tabasco sauce!
How to Make Homemade Cocktail Sauce
In about 5 minutes you’ll have this incredibly zesty and versatile condiment ready to enjoy.
It is so easy to make, I highly recommend that you always keep a batch on hand in the fridge. You never know when you’ll get a craving for spicy, tangy cocktail sauce!
Here are my simple steps for making the best cocktail sauce:
- In a small bowl, mix the ketchup, lemon juice, Worcestershire sauce, and minced garlic.
- Mix in prepared horseradish, tasting and adding more if desired. Add a dash or two of hot sauce for an extra spicy kick, if you like.
- Serve immediately, or store in an airtight container in the refrigerator until ready to enjoy.
That is seriously it! Feel free to add a pinch of salt if needed at the end!
Serving Suggestions
This easy cocktail sauce recipe can be paired with so many different things! It is a great condiment to pair with all things seafood. But it also goes well with veggies, french fries, or onion rings!
- With steamed, fried, or roasted shrimp (of course)
- Any seafood, including crabs, oysters, and crab cakes
- On burgers or a roast beef sandwich – like these mouthwatering Caribbean Shrimp Burgers
- With cream cheese and tortilla chips
- Mixed into tomato juice for an easy Bloody Mary base
- As a tangy veggie dip
- On a seafood pizza
- In a cool, fresh salad
See More Serving Ideas and Get the Complete (Printable) Shrimp Cocktail Sauce Recipe + Video Below. Enjoy!
Tips & Tricks
- Storage tips: Store your homemade cocktail sauce in the refrigerator in an airtight container for up to 6 months. If you don’t use it all, you can freeze half for later!
- Be sure to use prepared horseradish, and not fresh horseradish! Prepared horseradish has salt and vinegar added to make it extra tasty!
- You can use wasabi in place of the horseradish, if you already have wasabi on hand.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is cocktail sauce?
Cocktail sauce is a cool or room-temperature sauce that enhances the flavor of seafood, most particularly shrimp. It is made of a tomato base and seasoned with horseradish and citrus.
How Long Can You Keep Homemade Cocktail Sauce?
Kept it in an airtight container, in a refrigerator, this sauce will stay fresh for up to 6 months. You can also freeze cocktail sauce for at least 6-12 months.
Is cocktail sauce healthy?
It depends on your definition of healthy. Cocktail sauce is relatively low in calories and fat. Yet depending on how much you eat, it can be high in sodium and carbohydrates. If paired with shrimp or other high-protein seafoods, the carbs are balanced out.
Why does my homemade cocktail sauce gel?
Sometimes the combination of ketchup with horseradish causes the cocktail sauce to become a gel-like texture. It is simply a reaction of the two ingredients together! Stir it up well and it should return to a normal consistency!
Does making homemade cocktail sauce, rather than store-bought, really make a difference?
I 100% believe that making shrimp cocktail sauce at home creates the most flavorful and fresh-tasting sauce. There is no comparison. Store-bought cocktail sauce also has more preservatives to keep on room temperature shelves for longer. Whereas the homemade version will keep in the fridge and taste fresh for a good amount of time.
Looking for More Delicious Dip Recipes? Be Sure to Also Try:
- The Best Homemade Salsa
- Spicy Mustard Seafood Sauce
- Homemade Yum Yum Sauce (Shrimp Sauce)
- Southern Comeback Sauce
- How to Make the Best Tzatziki Sauce
- Easy Guacamole Recipe
Best Homemade Cocktail Sauce (Seafood Sauce)
Ingredients
- 1/2 cup ketchup
- 1 1/2 tablespoons fresh lemon juice
- 1 tablespoon Worcestershire sauce
- 1-2 tablespoons prepared horseradish
- 1 clove garlic minced
- 3-4 dashes hot sauce optional
Instructions
- Mix the catsup, lemon juice, Worcestershire sauce, and garlic in a small bowl.
- Add 1 tablespoon of horseradish. Taste and add more if desired. Then stir in a few dashes of hot sauce if you like your cocktail sauce with extra kick.
I just made this, it is literally the best cocktail sauce I’ve ever had! I will be making this frequently! Thank you for sharing your recipe!
I forgot to add the rating. Definitely 5 stars.
Hello greetings from the throne of God this recipe is fabulous the best I ever had I’ve made it before but not like this I love it thank you amen
This really is the BEST cocktail sauce! Quick question because I am following Weight Watchers; How many servings does this make/What consists of a serving?
Thanks in advance!
I put the horseradish in slowly but it still needed the full 2 teaspoons. Good sauce.
Pingback: Air Fryer Salmon Patties {Using Canned Salmon} - Dash for Dinner
Great recipe! Thank you. Will be making homemade cocktail sauce from now on.
This is the best recipe ever. I microplaned the garlic & added in lemon zest the same way. Added some fresh minced flat leaf parsley & green onions & it was the amazing. Could add in fresh dill, to taste. Love this recipe. Thank you!
I remembered making a darned good cocktail sauce last year, but couldn’t find the recipe I used, and came to this one through an internet search. I just finished making & tasting it, and thought to myself, “Dang, Bob, that’s as good as the one you made last year!”, and then I found the printed recipe I used last August.
Yep, it was this one!
:-)
Excellent. I added a bit of lemon zest to brighten the flavors. Thank you for your wonderful recipe.
Absolutely delicious! We like ours a lot spicer so we doubled the horseradish. We absolutely love how simple, fast, and fresh this recipe is. Bonus, we no longer have a crusty, old jar of half eaten cocktail sauce taking up space in our fridge. 5 stars!!!
I used to throw out so many bottles of cocktail sauce that had gone bad. Now I just keep a tiny bottle of horseradish in the fridge, which lasts forever. A neighbor recently called to ask if I had any cocktail sauce she could borrow. I said, “no, but give me 5 minutes.” She was blown away by this simple concoction.
Delicious! We needed a low-carb Keto cocktail sauce for grilled shrimp & veggies, so I used Heinz sugar-free ketchup and it is wonderful! So happy I don’t have to live without cocktail sauce! Thank you!
I did the same. It’s marvelous.
The sugar free ketchup is a lifesaver. I remember when I first did Atkins about 20 years ago, the recommendation was to eat shrimp with mustard! NO! :-) I made this with Heinz SF and it is perfect. Had never added garlic before–great change up!
My go-to condiments recipe reference whenever I make my gluten free breaded shrimp. I normally eyeball the main ingredients down to yield about 3 oz and one shortcut I use is Primal Kitchen’s Spicy Ketchup.
This was so easy and delicious! It tastes better than any seafood sauce I’ve had before. I don’t think I’ll add the garlic next time though. The horseradish gave a strong kick that we both loved.
Yup! Spot on awesomeness
Simple to make and super delicious. Thank you!
What is the serving size?
Hi Edward,
The serving size is one ounce, or about 2 tablespoons.
Tastes so fresh! Easy to make. I won’t ever use jarred cockatil sauce again! Thank you.
Love this easy cocktail sauce with prawns! The perfect summer appy!