The Best Potato Salad Recipe Ever

How To Make The Best Potato Salad Recipe – Today, I’m sharing our secret family potato salad recipe. My mom’s potato salad recipe is hands-down the best potato salad I, or anyone else who’s tried it, has ever eaten!

The Best Potato Salad Recipe… Ever.

My mom’s potato salad is better than your mom’s potato salad.

There, I said it, and I’m not taking it back! *wink*

Seriously though, my mother has magical abilities in the art of potato salad making. My mom makes traditional mustard, pickle, and hard-boiled egg potato salad. It’s simple, but I have never made or tasted another potato salad better than her version… And I’m not the only person to think so.

Over the years, I’ve watched countless relatives and friends swoon over her classic potato salad.

The problem is, when you ask her for the recipe, she has difficulty sharing it because she doesn’t have a recipe written down. She makes it by feel.

It’s taken years of watching, assisting her, and asking questions to come up with what I consider to be her recipe.

Want to know mom’s secrets?

Here’s What You’ll Need…

You need a few key ingredients to make the most comforting potato salad…

• Yukon Gold potatoes or Klondike Goldust potatoes – or use Russets
• Mayonnaise – your favorite brand
• Refrigerated pickle relish 
• Yellow mustard – or 1 part yellow + 1 part dijon
• Apple cider vinegar
• Celery seeds
• Paprika
• Hard-boiled eggs – peeled and chopped
• Celery stalks – diced
• Sweet onion – diced
• Fresh chopped dill
• Salt and pepper

How To Make The Best Potato Salad Recipe

1) The key to making the best potato salad is to use starchy potatoes and let them get really soft, so they are partially mashed once mixed. This gives the recipe a rustic, yet thick and luxurious quality. I like to use Yukon Gold or Klondike Goldust potatoes. You can also use Russet potatoes if you like. Do not use new potatoes, because they hold their shape too well and will leave the dressing soupy.

Start the potatoes in a large pot of cold water and bring them to a boil to ensure even cooking. Make sure to salt the boiling water so the salty flavor gets deep down in the potatoes.

Once the potatoes are soft, drain off the water and peel off the skins. You can leave some of the skins on if you like the added texture.

Chop the potatoes when they are soft; this saves time on the peeling and chopping.

2) Next, mix all the dressing ingredients together in a large bowl. Use your favorite mayonnaise as the base.

I know better than to tell you what brand to use… Mayonnaise is an intensely personal condiment!

Here in the Carolinas, we use Duke’s Mayonnaise, but mom usually uses Hellmann’s. You can even go with Miracle Whip if that is your favorite.

Mix a large amount of sweet pickle relish into the dressing.

Use the good quality refrigerated relish that tastes fresh, has large chunks, and stays firm. Otherwise, the dense, ultra-sweet shelved variety might overwhelm the flavor of the dressing.

If you can’t find “good relish”, finely dice firm refrigerated sweet pickles instead.

Make sure to use yellow mustard for flavor and color. Sometimes, mom adds half yellow mustard and half Dijon mustard, but if it’s going to be one or the other, you have to use classic yellow mustard.

Apple cider vinegar, celery seeds, and a little bit of paprika round out the dressing flavor.

3) Mix the potatoes and the dressing while the potatoes are still warm. Add chopped hard-boiled eggs for richness, celery for crunch, sweet onions for a zippy bite, and fresh chopped dill for a herbaceous punch.

The onions are a point of discrepancy in our family… Personally, I would always choose scallions over any other raw onion. However, my dad insists on raw chopped sweet onions for crunch and flavor, so that’s what mom uses.

To his credit, they do provide a more potent onion essence and crisp texture when served on the second or third day.

4) Finally, potato salad, any potato salad, tastes better on the second day after the flavors have had ample time to mix and mingle.

When possible, make mom’s this recipe the day before you plan to serve it.

However, if you don’t have time to make it a day ahead, refrigerate the recipe for as long as humanly possible before mealtime.

Get the Full (Printable) Best Potato Salad Recipe + Video Below!

If you are determined to learn How To Make The Family Secret Recipe, give my mom’s recipe a try.

I guarantee you will not be disappointed!

Frequently Asked Questions

What Type of Mayonnaise Should I Use?

The mayo is the base flavor in the dressing, so it is a very important ingredient. I find most people have a favorite brand. Go with your family favorite. If you don’t usually buy mayonnaise, Hellman’s is very popular, but Duke’s mayo is the brand of the South. *wink*

Why Sweet Pickle Relish?

Most brands of store-bought pickle relish are sweet. I like to use the refrigerated kind that has larger chunks. It provides a better texture, and the sweetness adds a lovely balance to the salad. If you hate the idea of adding sweetness, find a tart pickle relish or add chopped banana peppers. 

Can I Peel the Potatoes Before Cooking?

Mom always cooked the potatoes with the peels on, then removed some (or all) of the peels after cooking. This allows you to leave some potato skins in the salad, if you like, for extra texture. Also, it eliminates the need for a vegetable peeler because the skins will pull right off after the potatoes are fully cooked.

However, if you do not want to incorporate any of the potato skins into the salad, you can peel them beforehand. It’s a matter of personal preference.

Is This Recipe Gluten-Free?

Yes, as long as the mayonnaise is gluten-free, the whole recipe is. (Most brands are, but double-check your jar.)

Can I Make a Dairy-Free or Vegan Version?

Of course! This recipe is already dairy-free. However, to make it vegan, simply buy a vegan mayonnaise and then omit the hard-boiled eggs. 

How Long Does This Salad Last?

Stored in an airtight container in the fridge, this salad will last a week. 

Can You Freeze This Recipe?

I wouldn’t. The thawing process will change the texture, and the dressing will not be as creamy.

Can I Add Other Ingredients to Mix Things Up?

Sure! Try adding bacon, rosemary, scallions, chopped banana peppers, shredded cheese, or sour cream.

More Fabulous Make-Ahead Side Dish Recipes

• Perfect Southern Macaroni Salad
• Italian Pasta Salad
• The Best Broccoli Salad
• Provencial Potato Salad
• Market Bean Salad
• Hot German Potato Salad
• Mexican Street Corn Salad
• Pickled Banana Peppers
• Hoppin John Recipe
• Hawaiian Style Macaroni Salad With Potatoes
• Homemade Sweet Cornbread
• Buttermilk Drop Biscuits

Disclosure: A Spicy Perspective participates in affiliate advertising programs. We may earn a commission when you make a purchase through links on our site.

Share This Recipe With Friends!