Cinnamon Cream Pie
My cinnamon cream pie is for fellow cinnamon lovers who think a little sprinkle is never quite enough! I keep the filling easy with cream cheese and instant vanilla pudding, then fold in brown sugar whipped cream to make it light and fluffy. Spooned into a buttery baked crust and topped with the remaining whipped cream, it’s a holiday dessert I can assemble ahead and leave to chill.

Every November, I always get requests to share Thanksgiving desserts that aren’t pumpkin pie. Some people, no matter how hard they try, will just never love pumpkin pie. And that’s alright, because there are so many other delicious desserts that deserve a chance, like this cinnamon pie recipe that I shared last year! So, naturally, since you guys seem to have loved it so much, this year, I’m sharing an even more decadent version with this cinnamon cream pie. Imagine everything you absolutely adore about a classic cream pie, with a nostalgic and cozy holiday twist. Every spoonful starts with a crisp buttery crust, that is then filled with a no-bake sweetly-spiced pillowy center, and topped off with a dreamy, fluffy whipped cream. This dessert has become a new family favorite. It’s easy to make, a beauty to behold, and a true crowd-pleaser. One bite of this heavenly pie and you’ll be hooked!
Jennifer – ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I never leave reviews, but wanted to say thank you for this recipe. It is our go-to favorite pie recipe. I have made it yearly now for over 7 years. It never disappoints and always delights.
Table of Contents


Sommer’s Recipe Highlights
A Dreamy Pie – Now, I love a classic pumpkin pie, especially around the holidays. But sometimes I just want to shake things up, and this dreamy cinnamon cream pie does just that. It makes the perfect addition to your Thanksgiving or Christmas dessert buffet, and your guests will go wild for it!
Bursting with Cinnamon – If you’re a cinnamon fan, then this pie is for you! Every bite is bursting with those cozy fall aromatics that make you feel warm and snuggly. Those bold cinnamon flavors get perfectly balanced out with the creamy filling.
Easy and Simple – One of my absolute favorite things about a cream pie (like my banana cream pie recipe) is how easy and simple it is to make. This cinnamon version is no exception. All you need to do is prep and bake the crust, mix a couple of simple ingredients together, pour in the filling, and you’re ready!
Key Ingredients and Tips
- Pie crust – Every delicious cream pie starts off with a really good buttery pie crust. I like to buy a refrigerated roll-out pie crust, especially if I’m short on time, which usually happens during the holiday season. However, if you’re up for the challenge, make your own pie crust from scratch using my easy pie crust recipe!
- Heavy cream – In order to get that dreamy and fluffy whipped topping, you need to use heavy cream. It creates volume and that signature lift that we all love about this cinnamon pie filling. Make sure you use cold heavy cream to get those beautiful stiff peaks.
- Light brown sugar – I like to use brown sugar because it not only adds sweetness, but depth, caramel flavor and a subtle color to the whipped cream and filling.
- Cream cheese – I love adding softened cream cheese to the filling because it not only makes the filling creamier, it adds a wonderful tangy flavor that reminds you of cheesecake.
- Instant vanilla pudding – This gives that structure to the filling so that it comes out thick and perfectly sliceable.
- Whole milk – Don’t forget the whole milk! You’ll need it to activate the instant pudding.
- Ground cinnamon – And, of course, the most important element for that signature warm cinnamon flavor! A couple of spoonfuls of ground cinnamon totally transform a classic cream pie base into this holiday pleaser.
How To Make
Find the full recipe with ingredient proportions, detailed instructions, and a video tutorial in the printable form at the bottom of the post.
Prep the pie crust – Carefully fit the pie crust down into a deep pie plate. Then, crimp the edges to make them look pretty!
Bake the crust – Now, pop the crust into the oven at 450 degrees Fahrenheit until it starts to get golden brown. Pie crust without filling has a tendency to puff up while baking. To combat this, you can either prick the bottom of the pie crust with a fork, or place a piece of parchment paper down in the pie crust and fill it with dried bean or rice. Then remove the “weights” after baking.
Whip the Cream – To make that fluffy whipped layer, start by placing the cold heavy cream and brown sugar into a mixing bowl. Then, with a whip attachment, whip the cream until it’s firm and you’ve gotten those beautiful peaks. You can transfer the whipped layer into the fridge until you’re ready to assemble.

Make the filling – Beat the cream cheese to make sure its very soft, so the rest of the ingredients blend in. Add in the brown sugar and cinnamon so the brown sugar will break down into the cream cheese. Then, add in the instant pudding and milk and keep mixing until the filling is really, really smooth!
Assemble – Then, gently fold in about half of the whipped cream mixture into the pudding mixture and combine it very carefully until it’s light and even. Once that’s ready, carefully pour it into the baked pie crust and spread it out with a spatula.

Top and serve – Finally, top off the pie with the rest of that whipped cream and top it off with a generous dash of cinnamon powder. Chill for a couple of hours and serve!

Recipe Variations
- Pie crust alternatives – If you want the pie to be completely no-bake, use this graham cracker crust recipe instead of a traditional pie crust.
- Chocolate – Chocolate lovers, spread a layer of Nutella on the bottom of the pie crust before adding in the pie filling, for a sweet surprise. Then top the pie with chocolate shavings!
- Maple syrup – Add a drizzle of some maple syrup into the whipped cream or filling for a wonderful seasonal sweet twist!
- Spices – Try swapping the powdered cinnamon with a delicious apple pie spice blend!

Serving Suggestions
I love how simple yet impressive this decadent cinnamon cream pie looks. Those layers of tender and flaky buttery goodness and creamy, spiced fluff are just jaw-dropping good. Now, on its own, this dessert is a total stunner, but there are always a few tricks to dress it up, especially during the holidays.
- Drizzle some warm caramel sauce over the top of each slice and sprinkle a few crushed pralines, too.
- Serve this pie alongside some warm cinnamon spiced sauteed apples. It’s the perfect combination of sweet and slightly tart fall flavors.
- Top off your slice with some dark or white chocolate slivers for a real elegant touch.
- And, of course, don’t forget the ice cream! I love to pair this pie with a real generous scoop of homemade vanilla ice cream.
Storing
Whenever (and if ever) I have leftover cinnamon cream pie, I store it in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 2 weeks. But to be honest, the crust tastes best if it’s eaten within 1 week. Whatever you do, avoid freezing leftovers! The texture turns granular when thawed from the freezer.
Frequently Asked Questions
This is kind of like the secret ingredient to making a really good cream pie. Instant vanilla pudding really helps to thicken the filling to give it that wonderful creamy texture with no cooing required.
Great question! I use softened cream cheese because it just makes it so much easier to blend with the rest of the ingredients for the filling, without leaving clumps. I absolutely love the tangy, cheesecake-like notes that the cream cheese brings to this dessert.
A-ha! The secret to preventing a runny whipped cream is in using cold heavy cream!
Help Me Spread the Word about this Fabulous Free Recipe! Sharing this recipe link on Pinterest and Facebook is super impactful, and I greatly appreciate it! Find the share buttons below the recipe form. Also, join our NEW Spicy Squad Community Page to interact with me and other friendly cooks!
More Holiday Desserts
Cinnamon Cream Pie
Ingredients
- 1 refrigerated roll-out pie crust (or homemade!)
- 2 3/4 cups heavy cream
- 2/3 cup light brown sugar, divided
- 8 ounces cream cheese, softened
- 5.1 ounces instant vanilla pudding
- 1 3/4 cups whole milk
- 2 teaspoons ground cinnamon
Instructions
- Preheat the oven to 450 degrees F. Roll a store-bought or homemade pie crust out on a floured work surface, into a 14-inch circle. Hold one side of the pie crust over the rolling pin and carefully roll it over the top of the rolling pin to transfer it to a deep-dish pie pan. Don't stretch the pie crust, but gently move it into the center of the pie pan. Turn the edges underneath and crimp the edges to seal. Do this with a fork or with your fingers.
- Place a large piece of foil or parchment paper over the pie crust and gently shape it over the dough. Fill the foil with ceramic pie weights, or dried beans. Bake the crust for 10-15 minutes. Take out of the oven and cool completely. Remove the foil and weights.
- Once the pie crust is cool, pour the heavy cream in the bowl of a stand mixer with a whip attachment. Add 1/3 cup brown sugar and beat on high until whipped to firm peaks. Scoop the whipped cream out of the mixing bowl and refrigerate until ready to use.
- Next place the cream cheese, remaining 1/3 cup brown sugar, and cinnamon in the stand mixing bowl. Beat on high to soften the cream cheese. Then turn on low and alternate adding the instant pudding powder and the milk, until both are well combine and the mixture is smooth.
- Scrape the bowl with a spatula. Then beat again to make sure the mixture is completely smooth. Scoop half of the whipped cream into the pudding mixture. Gentle fold it in with a spatula until the mixture is light and even. Then scoop the filling into the prepared pie crust and spread out evenly.
- Top the pie with the remaining whipped cream and sprinkle with extra cinnamon. Chill for at least 4 hours, or until ready to serve.



I never leave reviews, but wanted to say thank you for this recipe. It is our go-to favorite pie recipe. I have made it yearly now for over 7 years. It never disappoints and always delights.
So happy to have found this recipe! During the Quarantine we’ve been watching Psych as a family and once we got to the episode about the cinnamon festival it put me on the hunt for a good cinnamon pie!! This was our favorite of the ones I tried. Today I’m making this a second time and tweaked it a bit using a nilla wafer crust. No matter how it turns out still a new favorite family recipe. 🤗💜😋🍰
Hi Stephanie,
I’m currently watching the same episode of Psych which is exactly why I decided to look for a good cinnamon pie recipe. So happy to hear the pie turned out well. I’m excited to make it this weekend!
Looks great! Will it hold up if made the day before?
Hi Emily,
Yes, you can. Happy Baking! :)