Smoothie King Caribbean Way Recipe – This refreshingly sweet fruit smoothie recipe is made with banana, strawberries, and papaya to create perfect copycat Smoothie King Caribbean Way smoothies.

Smoothie King Caribbean Way Recipe | A Spicy Perspective

Y’all, it is getting hot.

We are talking pavement melting, egg frying on a sidewalk, constantly sweating, bless my soul hot.

It must be summertime, huh?

As soon as the warm weather begins to arrive, we start to our cooling down plans, complete with sprinkler strategizing, and of course, getting excited about what deliciously cold and refreshing drinks and snacks we will enjoy all season.

Year after year my go-to drink for getting summer started right has been Smoothie King’s Caribbean Way Smoothie. It is seriously like a taste of tropical paradise with every sip!

Caribbean way smoothie in a tall glass with a pink striped straw.

The Best Smoothie: Smoothie King’s Caribbean Way

In today’s post I’m showing you how to make a smoothie at home by recreating my all-time smoothie shop favorite, the Smoothie King Caribbean Way. I’ve been buying this smoothie for over 25 years, and thought it was just about time to learn to make them myself!

If you have never had a Caribbean Way smoothie from Smoothie King, you have got to try this recipe. And if you have had them before, you will absolutely love how spot-on our homemade version is compared to the original tropical treat!

Ingredients needed for copycat Smoothie King smoothie.

What Ingredients You Need

There is nothing more refreshing than an ice-cold fruit smoothie that doesn’t require any yogurt, milk, or dairy alternatives! While I do love many cold and creamy dairy drinks, they don’t truly quench your thirst in the heat quite like a juice-based smoothie.

Sweet and refreshingly satisfying Caribbean Way smoothies are made with only 5 ingredients and your blender.

Here is what you need:

Turbinado sugar is made by pressing raw sugarcane, and is considered a lesser-processed sugar than say granulated white sugar. It is recommended that you used turbinado in this fruit smoothie recipe to add sweetness without any “artificial” taste, but in a pinch you certainly can use another form of sugar.

Brown sugar and coconut sugar have a similar, slightly earthy molasses taste similar to turbinado sugar, but are still considered healthier than granulated white sugar.

If you cannot find papaya nectar, you can substitute with pineapple or mango juice. The flavor of your Smoothie King Caribbean Way smoothie will be quite different, but still perfectly tropical and utterly delicious!

Strawberries and banana in a blender with papaya nectar being poured in.

How to Make Copycat Smoothie King Caribbean Way Smoothies

It is no wonder why smoothies are my favorite summer treat: They are just so easy to whip, or blend-up at home in only a matter of minutes! This copycat smoothie recipe is about to be your new favorite, too!

Here is how to make a fruit smoothie exactly like Smoothie King’s Caribbean Way:

  1. First, place the peeled banana, strawberries with stems removed, papaya nectar, and sugar in a blender. Cover and puree.
  2. Next, add the ice. Cover again and blend until smooth.
Cup of ice being added to the blender.

Immediately serve these smoothies while perfectly cold.

Bonus points if you have cute eco-friendly straws and tiny umbrellas for garnishing.

Get the full vacationing-in-paradise feel by enjoying this smoothie with Tropical Fruit Salad with Vanilla Bean or my favorite Ahi Poke Bowl Recipe!

Get the Complete (Printable) Smoothie King Caribbean Way Smoothie Recipe Below. Enjoy!

Caribbean Way Smoothie in a glass with another glass being filled.

How Can I Make This A Thicker Smoothie?

For a thicker Caribbean Way smoothie you can use frozen fruit in this recipe.

Slice and freeze the banana and strawberries an hour before preparing the smoothies, or you can use store bought frozen fruit.

What If My Smoothie Came Out Too Thick?

If the smoothie consistency seems slightly too thick and isn’t blending properly, try adding a splash or two of water at a time and blend again.

Hand holding a strawberry banana smoothie with a straw in it.

Looking for More Yummy Smoothie Recipes?

Print Recipe
5 stars (4 reviews)
Leave a Review »

Smoothie King Caribbean Way Recipe

Prep Time: 5 minutes
Total Time: 5 minutes
Smoothie King Caribbean Way Recipe – This refreshingly sweet fruit smoothie recipe is made with banana, strawberries, and papaya to create perfect copycat Smoothie King Caribbean Way smoothies. You'll love making these all summer long!
Servings: 2 16 oz.

Ingredients

US Customary – Metric

Instructions

  • Place the banana, strawberries, papaya nectar, and sugar in a blender. Cover and puree.
  • Add the ice and puree until smooth.

Notes

This recipe makes 32 ounces.
Want a thicker smoothie? Use packaged frozen fruit, or slice and freeze the banana and strawberries beforehand for at least an hour.

Nutrition

Serving: 1glass, Calories: 261kcal, Carbohydrates: 65g, Protein: 2g, Fat: 1g, Saturated Fat: 1g, Sodium: 5mg, Potassium: 585mg, Fiber: 5g, Sugar: 51g, Vitamin A: 38IU, Vitamin C: 102mg, Calcium: 38mg, Iron: 1mg
Course: Beverage
Cuisine: American
Making this recipe?Follow us on Instagram and tag @ASpicyPerspective so we can share what you’re cooking!

Share This Recipe With Friends!