Favorite Sugar Cookie Icing and Cut Out Cookie Recipe

Sugar Cookie Icing and Cut Out Cookie Recipe

Halloween, Thanksgiving and Christmas are just around the corner and I’m making lamb cookies?!? Yes, there is a method to my madness… Today I offer you my absolute favorite Sugar Cookie Icing and Cut Out Cookie Recipe for your holiday baking endeavors, and a story I’d like to call “On the Lam(b).”

A dear friend is expecting her first baby. Over the last few months a circle of girls arranged an elegant shower for her. We went with a lamb theme to coordinate with her crib bedding and proceeded to make lamb everything! It goes without saying that I would make lamb cookies.

Lamb Cookies

A member of the “shower committee” had an eccentric, yet inspired, idea. What if we had a live lamb in a crisp white pin at the entrance of the shower; wouldn’t that give the shower that extra spark? We were, after all, going for an unforgettable experience

Well, we hit “unforgettable” on the mark!

The day of the shower, the tables were set, the clean white tent was up, the decorations were hung, food was prepared, but our lamb had not yet arrived. The guests were pulling up and still we had no lamb.

Then finally, a pick-up truck arrived towing a fluffy white lamb. As our “wow-factor” was being unloaded a crowd started to form around the truck. The sweet little lamb gently gazed at the on-lookers, meekly waiting to be carried to his pin. We opened the crate to lift him out of the truck…

Suddenly, that lamb turned into a white blur and flew out of that truck at high speeds!

The lamb was on the run. Children were in hot pursuit. Ladies in heels were sprinting into the pasture to corral the lamb …but lambs are fast. Really. Fast.

Through the course of the afternoon, several people almost caught that lamb. Yet the lamb always wriggled free and was off in a white flash. At the end of the shower we called for backup. Husbands came and took the table clothes off the tables to use as a shield to coral the lamb… with no luck.

Finally, hours later, we had to call the owner to bring a herding dog to catch the lamb.

Moral:  Never invite livestock to a baby shower.

That being said, it was a beautiful, and most definitely memorable, experience.

Sugar Cookie Icing

My Cut Out Cookie Recipe and Favorite Sugar Cookie Icing were a big hit. And just look at the rolling landscape and the decorations.

Lamb Shower

After helping a crafty friend make paper fan mobiles, we decided to call for backup on the rest of the decorations. We asked Heather Preckel from Blissfully Sweet Designs to make us these precious and ever so intricate party banners. Heather is a master scrapbooker and Etsy store owner who makes the most beautiful party decorations you’ve ever seen. Not only that, she’s famous in her field. Heather’s designs have been published numerous times and  she is a regular speaker at craft conferences. Thank you Heather, you are a genius! (Make sure to take a look at her store.)

For the cookies, I used my most beloved cut out cookie recipe and sugar cookie icing, because it’s a sad truth that most “pretty” cookies don’t taste good. …and I hate that! This recipe makes a delicate tender cookie with a mild spice flavor that can still hold up to being rolled and cut. The icing is silky and dries with a satin sheen. It can be flavored and colored to use for any occasion, like your Halloween Party and Christmas Cookie Exchange!

Cut Out Cookie Recipe


Two words, COLD DOUGH. In order to produce cut out cookie with the perfect shape and texture EVERY TIME, the dough MUST be cold. Wrap your dough into several small disks, so you can take one out of the fridge at a time for rolling.

To make the bumpy “woolen” texture on the top of the lamb cookies, I cut the cookie, then sprinkled a handful of Rice Krispies on top. I gently pressed to cereal into the cookie, then removed the cutter, and placed it on a baking sheet.

Sheep Cookies


Yield: 36 large or 72 small cookies

Prep Time: 1 hour 30 minutes

Cook Time: 6-9 minutes

Sugar Cookie Icing and Cut Out Cookie Recipe


For the Cut Out Cookies:
3 sticks softened butter (1 ½ cups)
1 ½ cups granulated sugar
1 tsp. salt
2 tsp. Pumpkin Pie Spice
2 eggs + 1 extra yolk
1 vanilla bean, opened and seeds scraped out
3 ¾ cups all-purpose flour

For the Sugar Cookie Icing:
2/3 cup half-n-half
1 tsp. extract of choice
4 cups powdered sugar


Using an electric mixer, beat the butter and sugar together until light and fluffy—5 minutes. Add the salt, pumpkin pie spice, eggs and vanilla bean seeds. Beat to combine.

Slowly add the flour until the dough in smooth. Then separate the dough and wrap it in 4 separate pieces. Place in the fridge and chill for at least one hour. (Could be made weeks in advance.)

When ready to bake, preheat the oven to 375 degrees F. Line several cookie sheets with parchment paper.

Remove one disk at a time. Flour a work surface and roll the disk out to 1/8 to 1/4 inch thick. Work fast and cut the cookies as close together as possible. The more times you roll out the dough the tougher it gets. Use a thin spatula to transfer the cookies onto the baking sheets. Repeat with remaining dough. Bake for 6-9 minutes.

Cool completely on the cookie sheets before moving.

For the Sugar Cookie Icing: Whisk the half-n-half, extract and powdered sugar together until smooth. Add food coloring if desired.

Dip and face of each cookie into the icing, then set on a rack to dry.

Related Posts

63 Responses to “Favorite Sugar Cookie Icing and Cut Out Cookie Recipe”

  1. #
    Dmarie — October 30, 2011 @ 9:49 am

    what a hoot! you sure do showers to the hilt! love the cute little lamb cookies…will def remember these recipes when it’s time to do Christmas cookies with the grandgirls!


  2. #
    Skye — October 31, 2011 @ 11:43 am

    My mother in law caught a live chicken in the grocery store parking lot last week, and I thought THAT was an adventure. Y’all win.


  3. #
    Pauline — November 3, 2011 @ 5:25 pm

    Love the cookies and the lamb certainly made me smile. Where I live in the UK we have free roaming sheep so nothing surprises me there as they always go where you don’t want them too :-)


  4. #
    Terry Arnold — November 29, 2011 @ 7:55 pm

    Can these be made the day before? And, if so, should they be stored in the refrigerator because of the half and half?


    • Sommer — November 29th, 2011 @ 9:19 pm

      Hi Terry, I make them ahead and will leave them out on the counter a few days. But I’m not a health inspector. ;) We’ve never had an issue.


  5. #
    Tia — September 23, 2012 @ 4:02 pm

    These cookies are so adorable and I love anything pumpkin flavored. I got really excited to try them out but I can’t find a whole vanilla bean anywhere around me, do you know how much extract I could use instead? Thanks!


  6. #
    Stacy | Wicked Good Kitchen — March 1, 2013 @ 1:48 pm

    Sommer, these are the cutest and most innovative (for decorating) decorated sugar cookies I have ever seen for spring and the Easter holiday! So very sweet…just like the story in this post! Pinning… xo


  7. #
    Kristen — March 23, 2013 @ 4:20 pm

    I am laughing hard at that story! Too funny and such cute cookies :)


  8. #
    Laura Perry — March 23, 2013 @ 5:04 pm

    Those are adorable, and what a creative technique! I can’t wait to make these! Thanks for sharing. :)


  9. #
    Diana — May 3, 2014 @ 5:22 am

    Can you tell me where I can find the lamb cookie cutter that you used? Thanks.


    • Sommer — May 3rd, 2014 @ 5:47 am

      Hi Diana, I think I ordered it on Amazon a long time ago.


  10. #
    orgasm phase — August 8, 2014 @ 9:28 pm

    Wow, amazing blog structure! How lengthy have you been blogging for?
    you make blogging look easy. The total glance of your site is fantastic, as well
    as the content!



  1. Pingback: The Shiksa Picks – Tori’s Favorite Finds on the Web 11.4.11 | The Shiksa Blog

Leave a Comment